Your Customers Are Already Comparing You

Should you talk about your competitors?

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
Nearly every buyer compares options before deciding, and an Accenture report found that 94% of B2B buyers compare goods online before making a purchase. Brands that avoid talking about competitors leave that comparison to the customer, who often ends up borrowing a competitor's framing instead. Addressing the competition does not require attacking anyone. It can be explicit, like ClickUp's side-by-side comparison pages, or subtle, like Oatly poking at the entire dairy category without naming a single rival. Done with confidence, comparison builds trust by showing customers you understand their options and know exactly where your value lies.

Many companies would rather not mention their competitors at all. It feels risky, a little petty, and like free advertising for the other guy. But your customers are already comparing you, whether you show up for that conversation or not. The real choice is whether they hear your version of the comparison or someone else's.

Addressing Competitors

Reviews and testimonials help customers borrow the confidence of others. They answer the question “Does this product actually work?” But that’s only part of the battle in the Consideration stage. Customers are also asking, “How does this option compare to the alternatives?” In fact, research shows that nearly every buyer is making these comparisons. An Accenture report on business-to-business (B2B) consumers found that 94% of B2B buyers compare goods online before making a purchase decision.

When building trust, you need to address both the emotional reassurance and the rational evaluation that come with solution comparison. This is where many brands hesitate because it feels uncomfortable to talk about competitors. Yet avoiding the subject leaves a gap that your customers will fill on their own, often by relying on a competitor’s framing instead of yours.

Addressing competition does not mean you have to tear others down or resort to fear tactics. Instead, it can mean showing how your product or service meets customer needs in a way that is more complete, convenient, or compelling. Sometimes, this can be explicit through side-by-side comparisons, feature matrices, or website landing pages that walk prospects through the differences. Other times, it can be more subtle, woven into case studies, customer stories, or narratives that highlight benefits only your brand can deliver.

Again, the key is empathy. Customers are not asking you to insult other solutions; they are asking you to reassure them that you understand what matters most and that you have intentionally designed your solution with those needs in mind. That’s how you keep your brand top of mind.

Here are some examples for inspiration. In consumer goods, Oatly’s 2023 marketing campaign didn’t target one competitor directly. Instead, it cleverly poked at the entire dairy category with lines such as “It’s like milk, but made for humans” and “Wow, no cow!” The message was both bold and humorous, positioning Oatly as a modern, ethical alternative without naming specific rivals.

In the software-as-a-service (SaaS) industry, project management platform ClickUp chose a more direct path. Its “ClickUp vs.” website landing pages name competitors, such as Monday, Asana, and Trello, offering feature-by-feature comparisons and even guides for switching platforms. The tone is confident and playful, with taglines such as “ClickUp feels like Friday,” to reinforce simplicity and fun.

When done well, these strategies convey confidence rather than insecurity. You show that you are not afraid of comparison because you know your value is clear. More importantly, you demonstrate that your priority is not winning an argument but winning a relationship by helping customers feel confident they are making the right choice.

A Personal Case Study in Building Trust: Home Remodeling Startup

One of my earliest clients as a fractional chief marketing officer was a startup I often described as “the Warby Parker of home remodeling.” Their model was simple but meaningful: templatized kitchen and bathroom remodels, direct-to-consumer savings, curated design boxes shipped to customers, and digital design visualizers that brought projects to life.

When I joined, the mandate was clear: Increase qualified leads and scale advertising responsibly. My role was to set the marketing strategy, lead the internal team, and manage agencies and contractors. Almost immediately, I heard staff and external partners repeat the same concern: “We are being told to stay on brand, but we don’t know what ‘on brand’ means.”

The issue was not logos or colors. They already had an impeccable style guide with logo lockups, typography, textures, and photography. The real gap was in brand positioning and voice. Without those, no amount of design polish could create consistent marketing.

Working alongside their leadership and marketing team, I developed a brand strategy guide that went beyond visuals. It defined customer personas, brand positioning, voice, and personality. With that foundation, we set clear goals, budgets, and a road map to achieve them.

Once the strategy was in place, execution became dramatically easier. We onboarded new advertising and SEO agencies, empowered staff to manage social and email campaigns with confidence, and reduced friction between leadership and marketing. Every decision, whether creative, budgetary, or tactical, was filtered through the lens of strategy.

We also leaned heavily on customer insights. Reviews and testimonials were central to our messaging, helping prospective customers borrow confidence from past clients. On the comparison side, we utilized a simple but powerful website graphic: a side-by-side table of this company’s model versus a traditional remodel. It highlighted differentiators, such as pricing, timelines, contractors, design, and project management. That transparency turned what could have been a liability—customers shopping around—into an advantage.

The results validated the approach. Qualified monthly leads grew by 2.5x, while cost per lead dropped 15%. Creative assets, from videos to display to keyword ads, outperformed industry click-through-rate (CTR) benchmarks by as much as 38%. Organic traffic rose, social reach expanded across every channel, and a new landing page increased lead acquisition by 7.5x.

This company’s experience underscores that strategically building trust drives growth.

Wrapping It All Up

Staying quiet about competitors does not make the comparison go away. It just hands the framing to someone else. The remodeling startup turned customers shopping around into an advantage with one honest table on its website, and qualified leads grew two and a half times. Customers can tell the difference between a brand that is confident and one that is dodging the question.

If a prospect asked how you compare to your closest competitor, would your website already have the answer?


Interested in more?

This article’s content was adapted from the book Keeping People Interested: How Leaders Use Marketing to Capture and Sustain Attention, available as a paperback, ebook, and audiobook today.


Next
Next

Let your customers make the case for you